yetone 61e296688e gateway: Codex's model list keeps codex-auto-review when the user picked models on the ChatGPT account, so auto-review runs on it again, not on the conversation's model at low (#1460) ...

10086gg reported that Codex's auto-review through magpie almost never
used codex-auto-review. It ran on the conversation's own model at low
effort, which costs more.

Cause: codexModels narrows the ChatGPT backend's list to the models the
user picked on the codex provider (CodexNativePicked). Hidden entries
(visibility "hide") never reach magpie's catalog (parseCodexModels), so
no one can pick them, and the narrowing always dropped them.
codex-auto-review is one of those hidden entries. Codex 0.162 picks the
reviewer this way (codex-rs/ext/guardian-reviewer/src/model.rs,
select_review_model):
1. the entry's auto_review_model_override;
2. else codex-auto-review, if the list has it;
3. else the conversation's model, at low effort.
So once the list was narrowed, every review fell to step 3. On a relay
model it was charged to the relay; on a ChatGPT model it ran on that
model. OpenCodex had the same bug: lidge-jun/opencodex#6712 recorded
direct ChatGPT login as codex-auto-review/low and their proxy as Sol/low.

Fix: the narrowing keeps hidden entries. No picker shows them, so the
user's picks still decide what Codex's /model lists. A user who wants
reviews on a relay model can still set Codex's auto-review model
(#938), and that setting still wins (step 1).

Which account pays changes for a user with picks whose conversation
runs on a relay model: auto-review moves from the relay to the ChatGPT
account's codex-auto-review. That is what Codex does without magpie.
OpenAI's help article "Using Codex with your ChatGPT plan" says:
"When you're signed in with a ChatGPT account, auto-review safety
checks are free and don't count toward your plan's usage limits."

New test TestCodexModelListPicksKeepHidden. It fails on the old code:
after the picks only gpt-6-sol is listed, with no codex-auto-review.
docs/subsystems/gateway-routing.md says this.

Run:
- gofmt -l internal/gateway
- go vet -tags nogui ./internal/gateway, on darwin, linux and windows
- go test -tags nogui ./... with a temp HOME and pinned caches: green
Not run: a real Codex signed in to ChatGPT through the gateway. The
reviewer choice was read from the Codex source.

2026-10-10 13:30:43 +08:00

..

screenshots

gui: let users choose installed interface and code fonts (#1007)

2026-10-06 19:32:56 +08:00

subsystems

gateway: Codex's model list keeps codex-auto-review when the user picked models on the ChatGPT account, so auto-review runs on it again, not on the conversation's model at low (#1460)

2026-10-10 13:30:43 +08:00

code-standards.md

docs: the 10-08 review moves real use and GUI-in-both-engines into the code standards, adds gofmt and a Linux/Windows go vet to the checks, and adds lessons on Windows CI, telemetry disclosure, timing tests, guarantee tests, real vendor pages, CI's Go version and large commits without a body

2026-10-09 03:48:15 +08:00

contributors.md

docs: contributors.md lists lunar-me under authors reviewed with extra care (the maintainer chose not to block), with the evidence and what the extra care is

2026-10-06 04:52:27 +08:00

integrating.md

docs, site: Integrating your app or agent with magpie, at docs/integrating.md and usemagpie.ai/docs/integrate (#918, Magixyne)

2026-10-05 22:46:35 +08:00

reference.md

agent: Snow CLI is an agent magpie sets up: a magpie profile in ~/.snow, made the active one, that Snow App takes in with "Sync Snow CLI API config" (#1457)

2026-10-10 11:46:44 +08:00